Monsanto recently made a bid to take over European agrichemical giant Syngenta, the world’s largest pesticide producer. The $45 billion bid was rejected, but there’s still a chance for a merger between these two chemical technology giants.
Monsanto is reportedly considering raising the offer, and as noted by Mother Jones,
“combined, the two companies would form a singular agribusiness
behemoth, a company that controls a third of both the globe's seed and
As reported by Bloomberg, the possibility of Monsanto taking over Syngenta raises a number of concerns; a top one being loss of crop diversity.
“...[A] larger company would eventually mean fewer varieties of
seeds available to farmers, say opponents such as [science policy
analyst at the Center for Food Safety, Bill] Freese.
Another is that the combined company could spur increased use of
herbicides by combining Syngenta’s stable of weed killers with
Monsanto’s marketing heft and crop development expertise.
‘Two really big seed companies becoming one big seed company
means even less choice for farmers,’ said Patty Lovera, assistant
director of Food and Water Watch, a policy group in Washington.
‘From a public health and environmental perspective this is a
complete disaster,’ said Bill Freese... ‘The more I look at this, the
more it worries me and the more it needs to be opposed.’”
What’s in a Name?
According to one analyst, the takeover might boost Monsanto’s
reputation, as Syngenta has been “less publicly enthusiastic” about
genetically engineered (GE) crops.
Personally, I don’t foresee Monsanto ever being able to shed its
toxic reputation, no matter how it tries to rebrand itself. It recently
tried to do just that by declaring itself "sustainable agriculture company.”
But actions speak louder than mere words, and there’s nothing
sustainable about Monsanto’s business. Taking on the Syngenta name would
do nothing to change the obnoxious dichotomy between Monsanto’s words
In fact, Mother Jones astutely notes that by trying to acquire
Syngenta, Monsanto contradicts “years of rhetoric about how its ultimate
goal with biotech is to wean farmers off agrichemicals.”
It’s quite clear Monsanto has no desire or plans to help farmers
reduce the use of crop chemicals. On the contrary, it has and continues
to push for the increased use of its flagship product, Roundup.