Remembering War

As often has been the case, protest songs are often deflected by being sanitised of their political content. The Royal British Legion's 2014 Poppy Appeal single, is a version of Eric Bogle's classic anti-war anthem No Man's Land (The Green Fields of France) with some key lyrics omitted.

Eric Bogle has gone on record to distance himself from the British Legion’s version.

“The copyright for “No Man’s Land/The Green Fields of France” is held by my UK Publisher, Domino Publishing, who are ultimately responsible for approving applications to record this song. When an artist wishes to record “No Man’s Land” they must apply for a mechanical license to do so from the relevant UK agency, and pay a licensing fee. Permission to record is more or less automatic, especially if, as is the case with this song, it has been recorded before. At no stage in this process am I, the composer, involved. Generally speaking, the first I know of any new recording is when I see any subsequent royalties from the recording appearing on my royalty statements.

When the artist(s) in question records the cover version of the song, they can, and often do, rework the song as to be almost unrecognisable from the original version. This is especially true in Jazz music, and is generally regarded as an acceptable creative exercise by the artist(s). Although the publisher and/or composer could take legal action if they feel that the original essence of the song has been irrevocably altered and very much to the song’s detriment, this very rarely happens. The bottom line is that so long as royalties are paid, any wounded artistic feelings are usually put aside.

So then, to the most asked questions about this affair:
Was my permission sought when they decided to record this song? - No

Did I know what they proposed to do with the song when they decided to record it? - No

Do I approve of what they have done to the song ? (missing verses, rock’n’roll arrangement, etc) No, believe it or not I wrote the song intending for the four verses of the original song to gradually build up to what I hoped would be a climactic and strong anti-war statement. Missing out two and a half verses from the original four verses very much negates that intention. As to the musical arrangement, it’s really about whatever floats your musical boat. I would have thought a strong mostly acoustic version would have done a better job of getting the message across, but that’s just my personal preference, and I’m a bit of an old fart folkie. But then to do an acoustic version and include all four verses and choruses would have made the song nearly 7 minutes long, making it of doubtful commercial appeal in today’s modern music market, given that the average attention span of that market’s consumers is rarely more than three minutes or so. There’s not much doubt that the shortened, up-tempo, bluesy version that Joss does will probably appeal to a much broader cross-section of the listening public, certainly to those who did not know the song existed until they heard Joss’s version.

Is the strong anti-war message in the original song diminished in this recording? Yes, missing some crucial verses does not help. But then this diminishment is only in the eyes (or ears) of people who have heard the original version of the song. Those who have not heard the original cannot make the same comparisons or judgements. They must take Joss’s version on it’s own merits and make their own interpretation.

Does it follow then that this version glorifies war instead of condemning it? - No, in my opinion it certainly doesn’t glorify it, but doesn’t condemn it either, it just sort of starts off promisingly enough and then turns into a sing- along chorus type of song. Sentimentalising perhaps, but not glorifying.

Will me or my publisher be suing Joss Stone, Jeff Beck or the British Legion? — No, you have to be joking. I would have wished for a version of my song that could have been more true to my original intention in writing the song, but if Joss’s version touches heart [sic] or two here and there and makes some people reflect, perhaps for the first time, on the true price of war, then her version is as valid as anyone else’s.”

So, according to Eric Bogle,  the "strong anti-war message of the original song" has been diminished and sentimentalised by the Royal British Legion.

Eric Bogles own full performance can be listened to here

Well, how do you do, young Willie McBride?
Do you mind if I sit here down by your graveside? 
And rest for a while in the warm summer sun, 
I've been walking all day, and I'm nearly done. 
I see by your gravestone you were only 19 
When you joined the great fallen in 1916, 
I hope you died well and I hope you died clean 
Or, Willie McBride, was it slow and obscene? 

Did they beat the drum slowly, did they play the fife lowly? 
Did they sound the death march as they lowered you down? 
Did the band play The Last Post in chorus? 
And did the pipes play the Flowers of the Forest? 

Did you leave a wife or a sweetheart behind 
In some faithful heart is your memory enshrined? 
Although, you died back in 1916, 
In that faithful heart are you forever 19? 
Or are you a stranger without even a name, 
Enclosed in forever behind the glass frame, 
In an old photograph, torn, battered and stained, 
And faded to yellow in a brown leather frame? 

Did they beat the drum slowly, did they play the fife lowly? 
Did they sound the death march as they lowered you down? 
Did the band play The Last Post in chorus? 
And did the pipes play the Flowers of the Forest? 

The sun now it shines on the green fields of France; 
There’s a warm summer breeze that makes the red poppies dance. 
And look how the sun shines from under the clouds
There’s no gas, no barbed wire, there’s no guns firing now. 
But here in this graveyard it’s still No Man's Land 
The countless white crosses stand mute in the sand
To man's blind indifference to his fellow man. 
To a whole generation that were butchered and damned. 

Did they beat the drum slowly, did they play the fife lowly? 
Did they sound the death march as they lowered you down? 
Did the band play The Last Post in chorus? 
And did the pipes play the Flowers of the Forest? 

Ah young Willie McBride, I can’t help wonder why, 
Do those that lie here know why did they die?
And did they believe when they answered the cause, 
Did they really believe that this war would end wars? 
Well the sorrow, the suffering, the glory, the pain,
The killing and dying, were all done in vain.
For Willie McBride, it all happened again, 
And again, and again, and again, and again.

Did they beat the drum slowly, did they play the fife lowly? 
Did they sound the death march as they lowered you down? 
Did the band play The Last Post in chorus? 
And did the pipes play the Flowers of the Forest? 

Did they beat the drum slowly, did they play the fife lowly? 
Did they sound the death march as they lowered you down? 
Did the band play The Last Post in chorus? 
And did the pipes play the Flowers of the Forest?