Many on the Left are critical of Fortress Europe and its
lack of political accountability, but they are also generally positive about
the EU and see it as playing a progressive role in national, continental and
global politics. This does not mean that all of the Left are sympathetic to the
EU. The NO2EU campaign, backed by the RMT union, offered “left-led opposition to
the Euro super state” in European Parliament elections. The similarities
between this form of anti-EU politics and the anti-EUism of right wing parties
such as UKIP is alarming. Indeed the commonalities between far right and left
wing positions demonstrate the need for an explicitly anti-national as well as
anti-capitalist position.
Many on both the Left and Right of the political spectrum
see Europe as a counter-balance to rampant global capitalism. Europe is seen as
a blueprint for other societies to follow. Democracy and systems of state social
welfare are frequently mentioned by Bernie Sanders. Europe is held up as a
better model than the “casino capitalism” of America, for example. The supposedly
benevolent, enlightened EU is seen as an example of an alternative, socially
responsible form of capitalism.
Across Europe the far right, have moved away from explicitly
racist positions are now beginning to develop strong anti-Islam positions which
variously criticise Islam or its militant Islamist interpretation, focus on
some of the anti-democratic and oppressive features of specific forms of Islam
and argue they are incompatible with European ideals. This is a form of
exclusionism not explicitly based on racial prejudice but on the perceived
failure of Islam to adhere to what are seen to be European characteristics.
Rather than being a characteristic of the far right this hostility towards
Islam is now becoming a part of the normal political centre-ground. As well as
being seen as the site of a more “humane” form of capitalism, Europe is also
seen as the beacon of freedom and democracy. This has led many within the right
to portray Europe as being in conflict with “Islamo-fascism”. This discourse is
making its way into mainstream public debates. It is interesting that support
for this comes from both the moderate left and right of the political spectrum.
Both the pro- and anti-EU campaigners recognise that even by
current standards the EU is an undemocratic institution. They tap into and
appeal to populism by declaring Europe is run by and for the bankers, a regression
to conspiracy theories in which mysterious bankers pull the political strings
in order to ensure maximum profits. Indeed those on the Left arguing for a
Europe of peoples rather than bankers share a similarity with many on the far
right who also see Europe as under threat from rampant speculative capital. The
leave or stay positions share the same shortcomings: a false perspectives on
capitalism and therefore false solutions which will be unsuccessful and exclusionary.
Capitalism isn’t a conspiracy run by a cabal of fat cat bankers nor is it the
imperialist project of Merkel, Hollande and Cameron. The true secret of
society, the real power that drives it, is not that of an elite ruling, but
rather the social relationships that we enter into every day. We make
capitalism. To exit capitalism does not entail staying or leaving Europe. Support
or non-support for the EU is not and cannot be considered an anti-capitalist
position. It is important to recognise that the social welfare model that EU
supporters applaud was the outcome of the struggles of workers movements. We
cannot support the “enlightened” version capitalism of the EU; it must be
rejected. The EU is a political structure that is to help manage both capital
and populations. The EU is not and can never be an anti-capitalist structure. Our
critique is not geographical, about where the borders of our political
community should lie, nor is it technical, about the constitutional forms in which
the domination of capital over our lives take place. It is a class analysis. Workers
must be wary about getting sidetracked into discussing the management of
capital.