Sunday, September 13, 2015

When the Unions Are the Employers

Further to an earlier post on the exploitation taking place on tea plantations in the Assam region, this report describes the resistance of tea-workers at the other end of India, in Kerala. This is from an article by Binu Mathew, editor of Countercurrents website 

Munnar is a tea country, said to be the Queen of hills of Kerala. Millions of tourists both domestic and foreign flock to this hill resort to enjoy this sight, the cool weather and breathe ‘fresh’ air. Very few realize that behind all this natural beauty there lies tears and tyranny, trauma and helplessness of workers who toil in these plantations from dawn to dusk. Kannan Devan Hills in Devikulam Taluk comprising about 1,36,600 acres of land , was given on lease on 11 July 1877 by the Poonjar Royal family to John Daniel Munroeto during the British Raj for an annual lease rent of Rs. 3,000 and a security deposit of Rs. 5,000. In 1964, the Tata Group entered into collaboration with Finlay which resulted in the formation of the Tata-Finlay Group. Although the lands and plantations were later resumed by the Government of Kerala by the KANNAN DEVAN HILLS (RESUMPTION OF LANDS) ACT, 1971., the government of Kerala is only a lessor and the lease amount still stays the same. Tata Tea Ltd. was formed in 1983. After forming KDHP giving 'ownership' of the company to its employees, TATA now controls over a million acres of government land for next to nothing! There are allegations that TATA has encroached upon thousands of acres of government and forest land. V.S Achuthananthan of CPI (M) had vowed to get back all the encroached lands from TATA when he was the Chief Minister of Kerala. He couldn’t take back an inch of the land occupied by TATA.

Thousands of women gathered in front of the Kanan Devan Hills Plantations Company (P) Ltd (KDHP) office in Munnar are shouting this slogan in a dialect which is a mixture of Tamil and Malayalam in a low, slow rhythm. One woman sitting in the gathering of about 5,000 workers holds a placard which reads, “Green Blood Revolution, Strike Of the People, For the People, By the People.” In Kerala, which boasts that it elected through the ballot, for the first time in the world, a communist party government to power, where everything from birth to death are unionized, emerges a workers’ movement, that too led by thousands of women, literally driving away trade union leaders, as they term it, “A Green Blood Revolution”. All they are asking for is Rs 500 ( $8) daily wages and 20 % annual bonus, which even if they get it will be around Rs 8000 ($140) only. But their grievances go beyond that. Why is there so much support for these women, who are defying the trade unions who are supposed to protect their interest? The public feel that their grievances are genuine and they were betrayed by the trade unions.

Technically, the workers are touted to be the owners of the estate. It was in 2005 that Tata Tea Ltd, then owners of KDH decided to form as reported by Business Standard on March 19, 2005, "17 of its leased tea estates to a separate company called Kannan Devan Hills Plantation Ltd (KDHP), which will be owned by the employees of the tea estates." Tata Tea Ltd which later became Tata Global Beverages Ltd. holds 28.52% of share. Another 8.95 % share is parked at KDHP Welfare Trust. Workers are said to hold about 60 % of share of this company. V. Mariyappan, CITU (a trade union affiliated to Communist Party of India, Marxist, CPI (M)) area president says that the actual decision making power is still wrest with TATA employees. “There are two representatives of workers in the director board, but they don’t know what’s really happening. They just come for the board meeting and drink tea and leave,” says Mariyappan.

Now the question arises, where have the Trade Unions who should be protecting the workers’ right from the Corporate honchos gone? The workers allege that the trade unions took ‘three suit cases’ from the Management and betrayed them. They also released a list of 150 trade union leaders who received houses from KDHP Management. This list includes present MLA from the area S.Rajendran, former MLAs A.K Mani and Sundara Manikyam, AITUC leader C.A Kurian, G. Muniyandi of INTUC. To add insult to injury S.Rajendran M.L.A reportedly said that Tamil terrorist groups are behind the workers’ agitation. On Friday, he was chased away by the striking workers when he tried to meet them. He jumped into a police vehicle and escaped. To assuage the workers’ anger, S. Rajendran started a parallel hunger strike the next day asking the management to resolve the issue immediately. It is to be noted that no leaders, from the other two recognized unions, The Communist Party of India (CPI) affiliated AITUC, which is the leading union in the sector, and Congress affiliated INTUC so far have met the striking workers.

The KDHP general body held on 26th August announced that this year’s bonus will be 10 %. From then onwards, resentment was simmering. Women workers, who are predominant in the 10,000 odd work force of the estates, started a whispering campaign through mobile phones. On 5th September, some 50 women workers gathered in front of the KDH office and started the strike. Soon the word, spread around the hills and women workers gathered in hordes around the office. Soon they were in thousands. Men were kept away. When we went to Munnar on 12th September, it was day 8th of the strike. I could see about five thousand women sitting quietly in front of the KDH office. Occasionally there would be a burst of sloganeering. Then silence. There were hundreds of policemen surrounding the gathering. The police men, as is usual in protest and strikes, were not to threaten and disperse the crowd. They seemed, silently to support the strike. One police officer, even came forward to say that workers’ demands are genuine and should be widely reported.

It seemed that the whole of Munnar is in support of the strike. One shop owner where we had tea was eloquent in his support of the strike. Meals and tea are provided to the striking women by collecting funds from the shop owners, taxi drivers of Munnar. On the day of our arrival a temple committee provided free food for the striking women. One trader said, “If they earn Rs 1000 they spend it here in our shops for their basic needs. It is our duty to support them in their hour of need.”

A look at their salary slip will tell a bit of their plight. A worker’s basic pay is Rs 82.63 ($ 1.5) per day, with other allowances total daily wage is 250 ($4). That is, if they work 10 hours day, if they are late for work, they won’t allowed to work for the day, or if they leave early due to some illness or other necessities, hourly wages would be cut from this amount. According to labour laws, they need to pluck only 20 kilograms of tea leaves a day. But they work over time, daily, every day of the week, from 6 AM in the morning to 6 PM in the evening. However hard they work, they will be able to make Rs 300-350 per day. If they pluck up to 60 kg more than the legally required 20 kg, they will get Rs 36, if they pluck 100 kg a day, they will earn an over time of Rs 80 ($1.40). As food benefit, for three months, the company provides 75 kg of rice to each family. For this Rs 750 is cut from the salary each month. When the total price is calculated, it is just about the market price and way more than the rice distributed by the government through public distribution system. Yearly, Rs 200 compulsorily and a voluntary wage of one day have to be paid to the union fund for representing the workers. The houses they live are colonial style slave dwelling places. In fact, majority of the workers were brought from Tamil Nadu in colonial times as slaves, by the British when these hills were turned into tea plantations. Their living conditions or working conditions have not changed much since then. It has a kitchen and a one room which acts as living cum bedroom. A family of seven or eight people sleep in this one room. Even when a son or daughter is married, they sleep in the same room with their parents and siblings. The roof of most of these houses are covered with Asbestos, a carcinogenic material. International labour organization has passed "Asbestos Convention, 1986" which has been ratified by 35 countries. U.S. Senate passed Ban Asbestos in America Act on October 04, 2007 unanimously. Asbestos is banned in Europe since 1 January 2005.

Swami Vel a retired supervisor, said with guilt in his eyes, “now a Kankani is called a supervisor. But the work we do has not changed. We force them to pluck faster and faster. There are no such things as work breaks, even when they are having tea, they will be plucking tea leaves with the other hand. Women are not allowed take a break to urinate.” This slave labour is taking a toll on the health of many of the woman workers. Constant leaning over the tea bushes to pluck the leaves have damaged the uteruses of many women workers and have been surgically removed, testified many strikers we talked to. Although, KDHP runs a general hospital in Munnar, the workers can avail only three days of free in patient treatment in the hospitals. 

The constant usage of pesticides like Roundup is causing severe health hazards. World Health Organization in March termed Roundup as “probably carcinogenic”. The Forbes Magazine reported that "The decision was laid out in a new analysis in The Lancet Oncology, and published on the WHO’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) website. The analysis is based on the existing research on the chemical exposure in people and lab animals." Pesticide spraying is mostly done by male workers.

“The government, the KDHP management, and the trade union leaders have the responsibility to resolve the crisis and to ensure that the workers get justice. If that doesn’t happen, I fear, this ‘Green Blood’ revolution may turn Red. When you drink your morning tea tomorrow, look closely whether it has turned green, red or plain toxic.” - Binu Mathew

Contact the World Socialist Party (India)


ajohnstone said...

This blogger has spent several days in Munnar (wet and cold) and has visited other tea estates in Kerala and can vouch for the harsh conditions of these workers. In fact, from his personal observations, this blogger subsequently "upset" fellow members that come the revolution they will be missing their customary daily cup of tea because he envisaged a mass exodus of tea workers from their servitude once submission to wage slavery was no longer being imposed.

ajohnstone said...

In Kerala, India, thousands of women tea plantation workers have ended an unprecedented nine-day strike after their managers agreed to their demands to increase bonuses. The women blockaded roads in the hill town of Munnar. The strike was unusual because of the women’s decision to reject the involvement of male-dominated trade unions and almost all politicians.