Worried
about the state of the planet and what capitalism is doing to it?
Want to do something about it? But what?
- Burn
down a bank, maybe?
You could
do, but there's a lot of banks, and even if you burned them all,
they'd just
build them again.
- Kick
a copper, perhaps?
Maybe, but
they can kick harder than you can, every time.
- Bring
down the government?
And get a
different government in? Or get martial law?
- Start a revolution then?
Now
you're talking. But what kind of revolution? That is the question....
Opponents
of capitalism are used to having their names dragged through the mud
by the state but we don't need to help the bastards do it in
practice. Anybody who kicks in the window of a bank or a fast food
joint is handing the state a propaganda victory on a plate.
You can't
bring down capitalism in the street. At best you can temporarily
annoy it. Is that worth getting busted, or busted up, for? Don't
kid yourself that mayhem and rioting is a real threat to capitalism.
Modern states have massive coercive power, and they can stand a lot
more heat than you can deliver, and they can dish out a lot more heat
than you can take.
To be
dangerous to capitalism,we have to win the war of ideas, in the
newspapers, on TV, amongst our friends and co-workers, in our groups,
in our own head. And we have to be united about what we want after
capitalism, and united about how to get it. Otherwise, the grim truth
is that we really won't get past Go.
For a
revolution to be any good, you have to be for
something,
besides being
against capitalism. Some people are
just against big capitalism (WTO, IMF, World Bank, multinationals,
etc) as if somehow
'small' national capitalism is a completely different thing, and
perfectly nice.
It's not. They're the same. Let's have a definition: capitalism
is production for sale on a market with a view to profit.
Instead of
that we could have: cooperative
production for use and free distribution on the basis of need. This
would
involve: no markets, no money, no commodities, no private property,
no rich
class and poor class, no Third World and First World, no profit-led
profligacy
of any description, no ecological destruction, no famine, and no war.
Think
that's unlikely? It isn't. Capitalism has taken us as far as it can
go, but there's
a lot further we can go without it. It doesn't really matter whether
you call it post-capitalism,
world socialism, or post-scarcity anarchism, it is feasible and
desirable. And given that some scientists are talking about a point
of no-return for environmental destruction being reached, the word
'urgent' springs to mind
too.
"Instead of that we could have: cooperative production for use and free distribution on the basis of need."
ReplyDeleteSo after being liberated from the clutches of my evil capitalist boss who denied me the full value of my labor by appropriating my surplus value to pursue his own ends, which is clearly an immoral and inexcusable situation, I will find myself free to have the full value of my labor once again denied to me by someone else appropriating my surplus value to pursue their own ends, but because this time instead of feeding my fat boss, it would be going to some starving orphan in the middle of buttfuck nowhere I should feel all tingly and shit.
A boss is a boss and my labor is my labor and I don't care if you take out of my pocket to buy the finest caviar in the finest restaurant in the city or to feed the starving orphans; my pocket is still lighter than it should be.
If I'm going to support a revolution then I'm going to support one which promises to me that what I earn is mine to keep instead of this paternalistic bullshit that just trades one set of shackles with the inscription "Greed" on them with one that has "Altruism" inscribed on them.
Who mentioned altruism?
ReplyDeleteWho mentioned morality or its opposite?
There will be no starving orphans, or war ,or the poverty to which altruistic measures address their never ending focus. There will be no money to take out of your pocket, light or heavy, in the frst place, as it is a moneyless society. In place of the waged (rationed) access, is free access to all wealth collectively produced.
If you can lay aside your prejudiced blinkers long enough to read the following thenan informed discussion may ensue.
http://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/pamphlets/capitalism-socialism-how-we-live-and-how-we-could-live